By Kevin Davis
http://www.amazon.com/Normal-People-Some-Crazy-Things/dp/0981934307
Book review by Richard L. Weaver II , Ph.D.
The first thing
that concerned me when I began this book was where the “nine
fundamentals of human behaviors” originated. I searched the back of the
book for notes, sources, or a bibliography and found none. I looked at
the back of each chapter and even at the bottom of pages throughout the
book and found none. I checked within paragraphs to see if citations
were included, and I found none.
Then I found the
answer. Davis says, “I wrote this book to share some of my perspectives
about why people behave the way they do. I call these broad categories
of motivations that underlie people’s actions, ‘Fundamentals’ of human
behavior” (p. 5).
These are Davis’s
perceptions that “gelled over time as I worked with clients” (p. 5).
“In developing these Fundamentals, I attempted to categorize large
variations of human behavior into simplified, understandable and usable
concepts” (p. 5).
Davis’s nine
fundamentals are: 1) “Everyone is terrified and therefore
unreliable...until they’re not,” 2) “No one wants you to succeed too
well or fail too badly,” 3) “Genuine interest in and attention to others
is a rare commodity,” 4) “Most relationships, and their recurring
problems, are based on power dynamics,” 5) “Everyone is rushing toward
the white picket fence,” 6) “The Immature Masculine tries to run from or
dominate the Feminine,” 7) Everyone points the finger,” 8) “We all have
multiple personalities,” and 9) We are all addicted to intensity.”
“Ultimately,”
Davis writes, “these Fundamentals are ‘one man’s opinion’ and they are
intended to serve as a starting point for discussion” (p. 7).
Discussion starters. The problem, as I see it (and this is just one
man’s opinion!), is that there are no sources to support these
fundamentals. Why couldn’t the author expand readers’ perspectives,
reading opportunities, and research possibilities with “further
reading”suggestions?
The answer could
lie in one element: The author only has an M.A. He has not researched
his own ideas. He has no fundamental knowledge base except his own.
Throughout the book, to support this possibility, he includes shaded
boxes labeled “Author’s personal experience,” “From actual
conversation,” “Excerpt from coaching session,” and “From actual
event.” These are his sources. I wonder if Davis has ever considered
the fact that single instances, no matter how significant they may seem,
do not prove a point, and, too, can be slanted in any direction to make
or prove a point! They are not—by any stretch of the
imagination—evidence!
Now, I want it to
be clear that this is not an indictment of the book. After all, Davis
admits what he has done. Further, he is not asking readers to accept
his fundamentals as fact, truth, proven points, or validated
conclusions. He is presenting them as discussable issues. They are
designed simply to promote discussion. And, certainly, with that in
mind, they may well serve that purpose.
My issue with the
fundamentals is simply that for any reader who has done any significant
amount reading (or has a significant amount of life experience) will
find Davis’s “fundamentals” as common knowledge. How do you discuss
ideas that are fairly commonly accepted behaviors?
With all of this
said, Davis is a fairly good writer, has a sense of humor, and offers a
variety of interesting examples. If you are just looking for an
enjoyable book that may keep your interest for a couple of hours, this
is a worthwhile purchase. If you are looking for deep thinking,
well-researched ideas, or insights that you won’t find in numerous other
places, this book won’t help you at all. Davis, however, offers
practical information that has the potential to remind you of a variety
of interesting insights that may or may not offer you useful ways to
look at daily behavior.
Why normal people do some crazy things: Nine fundamentals of human behaviors can be purchased at Amazon.
Monday, July 2, 2012
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Have you read the latest book review? Have you read the book? What do you think? Thank you for your comment.